Universidade do MinhoEscola de Direito    
 
  Universidade do Minho
http://www.cedu.direito.uminho.pt
 
print   close
 
back 
  
Case VALE - Freedom of establishment
 
Judgment
Case C-378/10


Decision:

"On those grounds, the Court (Third Chamber) hereby rules:

1. Articles 49 TFEU and 54 TFEU are to be interpreted as precluding national legislation which enables companies established under national law to convert, but does not allow, in a general manner, companies governed by the law of another Member State to convert to companies governed by national law by incorporating such a company.

2. Articles 49 TFEU and 54 TFEU are to be interpreted, in the context of cross-border company conversions, as meaning that the host Member State is entitled to determine the national law applicable to such operations and thus to apply the provisions of its national law on the conversion of national companies governing the incorporation and functioning of companies, such as the requirements relating to the drawing up of lists of assets and liabilities and property inventories. However, the principles of equivalence and effectiveness, respectively, preclude the host Member State from 

- refusing, in relation to cross-border conversions, to record the company which has applied to convert as the 'predecessor in law', if such a record is made of the predecessor company in the commercial register for domestic conversions, and

- refusing to take due account, when examining a company?s application for registration, of documents obtained from the authorities of the Member State of origin."


 
back 
  © 2020, Universidade do Minho